Article 3415

Title of the article

A DISCUSSION OF REASONS OF “THE MIRACLE OF DUNKIRK” IN RUSSIAN HISTORIOGRAPHY
1950s–1970s

Authors

Kompleev Anton Vyacheslavovich, Candidate of historical sciences, associate professor, sub-department of general history, historiography and archaeology, Penza State University (40 Krasnaya street, Penza, Russia), an_kompleev@mail.ru

Index UDK

94 (100) “1939/45”

Abstract

Background. The problem of British-German military confrontation of 1940–1941 is an important aspect of World War II historiography. At that period Germany tried to expel England from the war militarily and diplomatically, on the one hand, and started preparations for the military aggression against USSR, on the other. The reasons of such a radical swing of German expansion are still very controversial in historiography. The aim of the article is to analyze the discussion of 1950s–1970s in Russian historiography that was devoted to understanding of reasons for bringing the offensive to a halt at Dunkirk in May, 1940.
Materials and methods. The article is based on the Russian historians’ works on the problem published in 1950s–1970s. It is written with the help of the dialectical approach to scientific cognition and the historism and objectiveness principles. The historism principle helps us to analyze the study subject in its genesis and in co-operation with other objects and events. The objectiveness principle application means that we’ve carried out the research trying to avoid any given value judgments and not working under any particular political conditions.
Results. There are two approaches to understanding of the reasons of “the Miracle of Dunkirk” in Russian historiography. According to the first, the main reason for giving “the stop order” is the desire of German military-political leaders to reserve tank forces for the final stage of military campaign against France. According to the second approach, Hitler’s political motives prevailed. Historians taking this view thought that he considered the evacuation of the British Expeditionary Force as an opportunity for an early peace conclusion with Britain.
Conclusions. The analysis of World War II historiography let us conclude that in Russian historiography the largely supported approach is that describing the reasons of bringing the offensive to a halt at Dunkirk by the necessity of French campaign.

Key words

World War II, “Miracle of Dunkirk”, Operation Dynamo, Battle of Britain, Operation Sea Lion.

Download PDF
References

1. Dashichev V. I. Voenno-istoricheskiy zhurnal [Military-historical journal]. 1962, no. 6, pp. 45–59.
2. Viduetskiy P. Voenno-istoricheskiy zhurnal [Military-historical journal]. 1963, no. 9, pp. 78–85.
3. Divayn D. Devyat' dney Dyunkerka [Nine days of Dunkirk]. Moscow: Voenizdat, 1965, 240 p.
4. Greler O. Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya [Modern and contemporary history]. 1971, no. 5, pp. 112–118.
5. Fuller D. Vtoraya mirovaya voyna 1939–1945. Strategicheskiy i takticheskiy obzor [WWII 1939–1945. Strategic and tactical review]. Smolensk: Rusich, 2004, 544 p.
6. Kieser E. Unternehmen «Seelőwe»: Die geplante Invasion in England 1940 [Operation Sealion: planned invasion of England, 1940]. Esslingen-Műnchen: Bechtle, 2000, 336 p.
7. Marix Evans M. Invasion! Operation Sealion, 1940. Harlow: Pearson education Limited, 2004, 277 p.
8. Yakovlev B., Eremeev L. Voennaya mysl' [Military thought]. 1950, no. 3, pp. 69–83.
9. Somin N. I. Vtoraya mirovaya voyna (1939–1945 gg.) [WWII (1939–1945)]. Moscow: VPSh pri TsK KPSS, 1954, 72 p.
10. Liddell Hart B. The Other Side of the Hill. Germany’s Generals, Their Rise and Fall, with Their Own Account of Military Events, 1939–45. London: Cassell and Co, 1951, 487 p.
11. Liddel Gart B. Bitvy Tret'ego reykha. Vospominaniya vysshikh chinov generaliteta natsistskoy Germanii [Battles of the Third Reich. Recollection of high ranks of the generals of Nazi Germany]. Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf, 2004, 367 p.
12. Deborin G. A. Vtoraya mirovaya voyna. Voenno-politicheskiy ocherk [WWII. A military-historical essay]. Moscow: Voenizdat, 1958, 431 p.
13. Sekistov V. A. «Strannaya voyna» v Zapadnoy Evrope i v basseyne Sredizemnogo morya (1939–1943 gg.) [“Strange war” in Western Europe and the Mideterranean]. Moscow: Voenizdat, 1958, 419 p.
14. Trukhanovskiy V. G. Noveyshaya istoriya Anglii [Contemporary history of England]. Moscow: Izd-vo sotsial'no-ekonomicheskoy literatury, 1958, 592 p.
15. Vtoraya mirovaya voyna, 1939–1945 gg. Voenno-istoricheskiy ocherk [WWII. A military-historical essay]. Eds. by S. P. Platonov, N. G. Pavlenko, I. V. Parot'kin. Moscow: Voenizdat, 1958, 932 p.
16. Istoriya Velikoy Otechestvennoy voyny Sovetskogo Soyuza 1941–1945: v 6 t. [History of the Great Patriotic War of the Soviet Union 1941–1945: in 6 volumes]. Ed. by P. N. Pospelov. Moscow: Voenizdat, 1960, vol. 1, 533 p.
17. Bezymenskiy L. A. Germanskie generaly – s Gitlerom i bez nego [German generals – with and without Hitler]. Moscow: Mysl', 1964, 533 p.
18. Proektor D. M. Voyna v Evrope. 1939–1941 [War in Europe. 1939–1941]. Moscow:Voenizdat, 1963,437 p.
19. Proektor D. M. Agressiya i katastrofa. Vysshee voennoe rukovodstvo fashistskoy Germanii vo Vtoroy mirovoy voyne 1939–1945 [Aggression and catastrophe. High military leadership of Facist Germany during WWII 1939–1945]. Moscow: Nauka, 1968, 638 p.
20. Nekrich A. M. Voyna, kotoruyu nazvali «strannoy» [The war called a “strange” one]. Moscow: Izd-vo AN SSSR, 1961, 160 p.
21. Nekrich A. M. Vneshnyaya politika Anglii v gody Vtoroy mirovoy voyny (1939–1941) [The foreign policy of England during WWII (1939–1941)]. Moscow: Izd-vo AN SSSR, 1963, 532 p.
22. Dashichev V. I. Bankrotstvo strategii germanskogo fashizma: Istoricheskie ocherki. Dokumenty i materialy: v 2 t. [Bankruptcy of German facism’s strategies: Historical essays. Documents and materials: in 2 volumes]. Moscow: Nauka, 1973, vol. 1, Podgotovka i razvertyvanie natsistskoy agressii v Evrope 1933–1941, 766 p.
23. Liddel Gart B. Vtoraya mirovaya voyna. Ocherk [WWII. An essay]. Moscow: Voenizdat, 1976, 679 p.
24. Liddel Gart B. Strategiya nepryamykh deystviy [A strategy of unpleasant actions]. Moscow: AST; Saint-Petersburg: Terra Fantastica, 1999, 656 p.
25. Proektor D. M. Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya [Modern and contemporary history]. 1969, no. 5, pp. 94–108.
26. Dashichev V. I. Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya [Modern and contemporary history]. 1970, no. 1, pp. 126–146.
27. Istoriya Vtoroy mirovoy voyny 1939–1945: v 12 t. [History of WWII 1939–1945: in 12 volumes]. Ed. by A. A. Grechko. Moscow: Voenizdat, 1974, vol. 3, 502 p.
28. Bezymenskiy L. A. Razgadannye zagadki Tret'ego reykha. 1933–1945 [Solved riddles of the Third Reich]. Moscow: APN, 1980, 280 p.
29. Proektor D. M. Fashizm: put' agressii i gibeli [Facism: way of aggression and death]. Moscow: Nauka, 1985, 543 p.
30. Mirovye voyny KhKh veka: v 4 kn. [World wars of the 20th century: in 4 books] Ed. by E. N. Kul'kov. Moscow: Nauka, 2002, bk. 3, Vtoraya mirovaya voyna: Istoricheskiy ocherk, 597 p.
31. Plenkov O. Yu. Tretiy Reykh. Voyna: do kriticheskoy cherty [The Third Reich. War: to the critical boundary]. Saint-Petersburg: Neva, 2005, 384 p.
32. Smirnov V. P. Kratkaya istoriya Vtoroy mirovoy voyny [Brief history of WWII].Moscow:Ves' Mir,2005,352 p.

 

Дата создания: 06.05.2016 09:41
Дата обновления: 11.05.2016 09:12